Ruling by
Stuart R. PollakLower Court
Alameda County Superior CourtLower Court Judge
Daniel J. HealyProposition 57 mandates parole consideration after inmates serve full term of primary offense; 'two-tiered' system disqualifying certain otherwise eligible-inmates does not comport with the proposition.
Court
California Courts of Appeal 1DCA/4Cite as
2019 DJDAR 4243Published
May 20, 2019Filing Date
May 16, 2019Opinion Type
ModificationDisposition Type
Petition GrantedIn re TIJUE ADOLPHUS McGHEE
on Habeas Corpus.
No. A153721
(Alameda County
Super. Ct. No. FCR331651)
California Courts of Appeal
First Appellate District
Division Four
Filed May 16, 2019
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION;
NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT
Trial judge: Honorable Daniel Healy
Counsel for petitioner: Jonathan Soglin and L. Richard Braucher by appointment of the Court of Appeal
Counsel for respondent:
Xavier Becerra, Attorney General,
Phillip J. Lindsay, Senior Assistant Attorney General
Sara J. Romano, Supervising Deputy Attorney General Brian C. Kinney, Deputy Attorney General
THE COURT:
It is ordered that the opinion filed herein on April 29, 2019, be modified as follows:
On page 10, at the end of the first sentence in the last paragraph insert: ---to "ensure[] that the board focuses its resources on inmates who are more likely to be found suitable for parole." (Statement of Reasons, p. 17.), and delete the second sentence, so that the first two sentences read:
We do not gainsay the practical issues presented by implementation of section 32, subdivision (a)(1) as intended, nor do we fail to recognize the sensible rationale underlying the department's two-tiered scheme---to "ensure[] that the board focuses its resources on inmates who are more likely to be found suitable for parole." (Statement of Reasons, p. 17.) Nonetheless, although an inmate may not be paroled soon after committing such an offense, the appearance before the board may still serve a constructive purpose.
There is no change in the judgment.
Date: May 16, 2019 Acting P.J.
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424