Ruling by
Martin N. BuchananLower Court
San Diego County Superior CourtLower Court Judge
Timothy B. TaylorPetitioner's peremptory challenge to judge reassigned to her case filed before trial began was timely where the parties were notified of the reassignment via telephone call from the court clerk.
Court
California Courts of Appeal 4DCA/1Cite as
2024 DJDAR 4876Published
Jun. 6, 2024Filing Date
Jun. 4, 2024Opinion Type
ModificationDisposition Type
Petition GrantedLEAH LORCH,
Petitioner,
v.
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY,
Respondent;
KIA MOTORS AMERICA, INC.,
Real Party in Interest.
No. D083609
(San Diego County Super. Ct. No. 37-2020-00043357-CU-BC-CTL)
California Court of Appeal
Fourth Appellate District
Division One
Filed June 4, 2024
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION
NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT
THE COURT:
The court on its own motion orders this opinion, filed on May 16, 2024, modified as follows:
On the second line of page 9, the notation "[cleaned up]" is deleted.
In the preceding sentence beginning on the bottom of page 8 and continuing on page 9, the quotation marks are deleted.
On the eighth line of page 9, the notation "[cleaned up]" is deleted.
In the preceding sentence, the quotation marks are deleted.
On the last line of the first paragraph on page 11, the notation "[cleaned up]" is deleted.
The preceding three sentences, beginning with "The master calendar exception envisions" and ending with "does not apply" are deleted. They are replaced with the following:
"The master calendar exception envisions that the parties' attorneys are personally before the court when the assignment is made. It requires the challenge be made immediately upon the assignment in order to permit the 'judge in the master calendar department to make an immediate assignment to another department and immediately to utilize the challenged judge for some other pending case.' " The court added: "[W]hen the parties were not present before the court when the assignment was made by a clerk for trial to begin in a few days, the rationale for the master calendar rule does not apply."
In the Disposition on the last line of page 15, the words "against Lorch" are deleted.
There is no change in judgment.
BUCHANAN, Acting P. J.
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424