For reprint rights or to purchase a copy of your Daily Journal photo, email jeremy@reprintpros.com for prices or call 949-702-5390.

To buy more copies, call 866-531-1492 or email subscribe@dailyjournal.com
This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.
Menu
  • Sign In
    • Subscribe to the Daily Journal for access to Daily Appellate Reports, Verdicts, Judicial Profiles and more...
    Daily appellate reports
    Sign up for Daily Journal emails
      Filter by date
       to 
      Search by Case Name
      Search by Judge
      Search by Case Number
      Search by DJ Citation Number
      Search by Category
      Search by Court
    Name Category Published
    Chinaryan v. City of Los Angeles
    LAPD officers were not entitled to qualified immunity after conducting a high-risk vehicle stop based on nothing more than a reasonable suspicion that the vehicle was stolen.     		Qualified Immunity, Constitutional Law 9th Aug. 15, 2024
    Scott v. Smith
    No qualified immunity on Fourth Amendment excessive force claim, where police used bodyweight force on the back of a prone individual suffering from a mental illness and not suspected of a crime.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jul. 31, 2024
    Rosenbaum v. City of San Jose
    Officers not entitled to qualified immunity where their conduct of allowing a police dog to continue biting a suspect under control had been clearly established by precedent as violative.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jul. 12, 2024
    Cuevas v. City of Tulare
    Qualified immunity shielded officers from excessive force claim based on them returning fire at a suspect in a vehicle and wounding a passenger who was not suspected of any wrongdoing.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jul. 11, 2024
    Calonge v. City of San Jose
    An officer was not entitled to qualified immunity for using deadly force where there was conflicting evidence regarding the circumstances preceding the shooting.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jun. 10, 2024
    Carley v. Aranas
    Prison medical director was entitled to qualified immunity for denying treatment to inmate with Hepatitis C because there was no legal consensus regarding constitutionally sufficient treatment for such patients.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jun. 4, 2024
    Hart v. City of Redwood City
    Officers' use of deadly force was objectively reasonable where the deceased was not responding to commands and quickly approaching with a raised knife.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 22, 2024
    Perez v. City of Fresno
    Paramedic was immune from liability for death of patient caused by requesting an officer sit on patient to help secure him for medical transport because paramedic acted with a medical purpose.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 16, 2024
    Estate of Hernandez v. City of Los Angeles
    Although reasonable jury could have concluded officer used excessive force, qualified immunity shielded her because no precedent squarely governed shooting wounded suspect a sixth time as he attempted to stand.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Mar. 22, 2024
    Martinez v. High
    Officer who disclosed confidential report of abuse to plaintiff's abuser was entitled to qualified immunity because the violation was not yet clearly established.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jan. 29, 2024
    Waid v. County of Lyon
    Defendants were entitled to qualified immunity on plaintiffs' Fourth Amendment excessive force claim where officers shot the unarmed decent as he charged down a short hallway towards them.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Nov. 22, 2023
    Smith v. Agdeppa
    Summary judgment based on qualified immunity was not proper where there was evidence in the record that contradicted the officer's description of events surrounding his use of deadly force.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jan. 3, 2023
    Peck v. Montoya
    Deputies that did not shoot and kill decedent were entitled to qualified immunity on plaintiff's excessive-force claim because they were not integral participants in the constitutional violation.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Oct. 19, 2022
    Simmons v. Arnett
    Prison guard was entitled to qualified immunity because prisoner failed to satisfy his burden to show that the Eighth Amendment rights allegedly violated were clearly established.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Sep. 1, 2022
    Manriquez v. Ensley
    Officers were entitled to qualified immunity for Fourth Amendment violation stemming from failure to amend warrant to include judge's oral authorization expanding the warrant's scope.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Aug. 31, 2022
    Seidner v. De Vries
    Police officer was entitled to qualified immunity because his use of a roadblock to stop a fleeing bicyclist was a use of reasonable force under the circumstances.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jul. 1, 2022
    Hughes v. Rodriguez
    Officer was not entitled to qualified immunity as to escaped inmate's claimed post-handcuff beating and dog-biting during apprehension because beating a handcuffed convict violates the Eighth Amendment.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 22, 2022
    Estate of Najera Aguirre v. County of Riverside
    Police officer was not entitled to summary judgment based on qualified immunity because evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to plaintiffs, showed that his use of force was not objectively reasonable.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Mar. 25, 2022
    Benavidez v. County of San Diego
    Precedent establishes right to be free from judicial deception in child custody proceedings; thus, dismissal on qualified immunity grounds was reversed.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 13, 2021
    Jessop v. City of Fresno
    Appellants failed to show that it was clearly established that Officers' alleged conduct violated Fourth Amendment; thus, Officers were protected by qualified immunity.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Sep. 5, 2019
    Nicholson v. Gutierrez
    Because no analogous case existed at the time, district court erred by denying officer qualified immunity on plaintiffs' Fourth Amendment substantive due process claim.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Aug. 22, 2019
    Emmons v. City of Escondido
    Where cited cases are not 'sufficiently similar' to place 'constitutional question beyond dispute,' qualified immunity must be granted to law enforcement officer.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 26, 2019
    Horton v. City of Santa Maria
    Case law at the time involved circumstances too distinct to establish that a reasonable officer would perceive a substantial risk that detainee would imminently attempt suicide; thus officer entitled to qualified immunity.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Feb. 4, 2019
    Hines v. Youseff
    Right to be free from heightened exposure to Valley Fever spores in California state prisons was not clearly established at the time; thus, defendant officials were entitled to qualified immunity.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Feb. 4, 2019
    Escondido v. Emmons
    For qualified immunity to be denied, 'clearly established right at issue must be defined with specificity;' not sufficient specificity where court relies on fairly general right 'to be free of excessive force.'     		Qualified Immunity USSC Jan. 8, 2019
    Whalen v. McMullen
    Because it was not clearly established that officer's warrantless ruse-entry, in the context of civil investigation related to a determination of benefits eligibility, constituted 'unreasonable search,' he was entitled to qualified immunity.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Oct. 31, 2018
    Mellen v. Winn
    Qualified immunity improperly granted in civil rights suit where officer withheld material impeachment evidence about unreliable paid informant.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Aug. 20, 2018
    Pike v. Hester
    Sheriff’s sergeant who conducts nonconsensual dog search of public employee’s office is not entitled to qualified immunity where sergeant violates clearly established right.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jun. 7, 2018
    Felarca v. Birgeneau
    Summary judgment on qualified immunity grounds should have been granted where campus law enforcement used reasonable means to disperse Occupy Wall Street protest.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Jun. 1, 2018
    Amended Opinion: Demaree v. Pederson
    Qualified Immunity does not protect a government official when they violate an established right a reasonable person would know.     		Qualified Immunity 9th Apr. 9, 2018
    By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy. You can learn more about how we use cookies by reviewing our Privacy Policy here.