For reprint rights or to purchase a copy of your Daily Journal photo, email jeremy@reprintpros.com for prices or call 949-702-5390.

To buy more copies, call 866-531-1492 or email subscribe@dailyjournal.com
This is the property of the Daily Journal Corporation and fully protected by copyright. It is made available only to Daily Journal subscribers for personal or collaborative purposes and may not be distributed, reproduced, modified, stored or transferred without written permission. Please click "Reprint" to order presentation-ready copies to distribute to clients or use in commercial marketing materials or for permission to post on a website. and copyright (showing year of publication) at the bottom.
Menu
  • Sign In

    • Patrick J. Bumatay

    See more on Patrick J. Bumatay

    Circuit Judge
    9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
    CA Southern - San Diego





    Harvard Law School



    Rulings
    Case Category Published
    Garraway v. Ciufo
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Sep. 4, 2024
    Brown v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
    dissenting
    		 Tax Aug. 29, 2024
    Chong v. U.S.
    concurring
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 14, 2024
    Clements v. Madden
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 9, 2024
    Kumar v. Garland
    dissenting
    		 Immigration Aug. 5, 2024
    U.S. v. Hernandez
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jun. 28, 2024
    U.S. v. Leopoldo Rivera-Valdes
    concurring
    		 Immigration Jun. 17, 2024
    Sidibe v. Sutter Health
    dissenting
    		 Antitrust Jun. 4, 2024
    Walter Betschart v. State of Oregon
    dissenting
    		 Prisoners' Rights May 31, 2024
    Friends of the Inyo v. United States Forest Service
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law May 21, 2024
    BBK Tobacco & Foods LLP v. Central Coast Agriculture Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Intellectual Property Apr. 1, 2024
    U.S. v. Lemus
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Mar. 5, 2024
    Sherman v. Gittere
    author
    		 Prisoners' Rights Feb. 9, 2024
    Martinez v. High
    concurring
    		 Qualified Immunity Jan. 26, 2024
    Coalition on Homelessness v. City and County of San Francisco
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Jan. 11, 2024
    Amended Opinion: California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley
    author
    		 Environmental Law Jan. 2, 2024
    Miller v. City of Scottsdale
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Dec. 8, 2023
    Kohn v. State Bar of California
    dissenting
    		 Attorneys Dec. 6, 2023
    Amalgamated Bank v. Facebook, Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Securities Oct. 18, 2023
    Solar Energy Industries Assoc. v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law Sep. 5, 2023
    Oracle USA Inc. v. Rimini Street Inc.
    author
    		 Copyright Aug. 24, 2023
    Murguia v. Langdon
    dissenting
    		 Jul. 18, 2023
    Davis v. Cranfield Aerospace Solutions, Ltd.
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Jun. 23, 2023
    Enigma Software Group USA LLC v. Malwarebytes, Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Commercial Law Jun. 2, 2023
    Estate of Strickland v. Nevada County
    author
    		 Civil Rights May 31, 2023
    U.S. v. Williams
    author
    		 Attorneys May 18, 2023
    California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley
    author
    		 Environmental Law Apr. 17, 2023
    Duke v. Gastelo
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Apr. 5, 2023
    City of Los Angeles v. Federal Aviation Administration
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law Mar. 29, 2023
    Seaview Trading LLC v. Commisssioner of Internal Revenue
    dissenting
    		 Tax Mar. 10, 2023
    Rodriguez Diaz v. Merrick Garland, et al
    concurring
    		 Constitutional Law Nov. 21, 2022
    In re: Sandra J. Tillman
    dissenting
    		 Bankruptcy Nov. 18, 2022
    Verdun v. City of San Diego
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Oct. 26, 2022
    Cody v. Kijakazi
    author
    		 Administrative Agencies Sep. 8, 2022
    Klamath Irrigation District v. Shasta View Irrigation District
    concurring
    		 Civil Procedure Sep. 8, 2022
    Vanegas v. City of Pasadena
    concurring
    		 Civil Rights Aug. 31, 2022
    Chicken Ranch Rancheria v. State of California
    dissenting
    		 Gaming Jul. 28, 2022
    U.S. v. Oliver
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jul. 22, 2022
    California River Watch v. City of Vacaville
    author
    		 Environmental Law Jul. 1, 2022
    U.S. v. David
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jun. 15, 2022
    Martinez v. Clark
    author
    		 Immigration Jun. 15, 2022
    Inter-Cooperative Exchange v. U.S. Dept. of Commerce
    author
    		 Government Jun. 7, 2022
    U.S. v. Randall
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure May 23, 2022
    Seaview Trading v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
    author
    		 Tax May 12, 2022
    U.S. v. Kirilyuk
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Apr. 4, 2022
    Amended Opinion: Martinez-Gonzalez v. Elkhorn Packing RULING BY
    author
    		 Arbitration Feb. 15, 2022
    U.S. v. Orrock
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jan. 27, 2022
    Johnson v. Baker
    author
    		 Civil Rights Jan. 27, 2022
    City of Oakland v. Oakland Raiders
    concurring
    		 Antitrust Dec. 3, 2021
    Duncan v. Bonta
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Dec. 2, 2021
    D.D. v. Los Angeles Unified School District
    dissenting
    		 Disability Discrimination Nov. 22, 2021
    Center for Community Action v. Federal Aviation Administration
    concurring
    		 Environmental Law Nov. 19, 2021
    Martinez-Gonzalez v. Elkhorn Packing
    author
    		 Arbitration Nov. 4, 2021
    California River Watch v. City of Vacaville
    author
    		 Environmental Law Sep. 30, 2021
    Sanders v. City of Pittsburg
    author
    		 Civil Rights Sep. 24, 2021
    Center for Investigative Reporting v. U.S. Dept. of Justice
    dissenting
    		 Government Sep. 24, 2021
    Landis v. Wash. State MLB Stadium Pub. Facilities Dist.
    concurring
    		 Disability Discrimination Sep. 2, 2021
    U.S. v. Ferguson
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 18, 2021
    Bahr v. Regan
    concurring
    		 Environmental Law Jul. 29, 2021
    United States v. Charley
    concurring
    		 Evidence Jun. 14, 2021
    Magadia v. Wal-Mart Associates
    author
    		 Labor Law Jun. 1, 2021
    Olean Wholesale Grocery Cooperative, Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Apr. 7, 2021
    Diaz-Flores v. Garland
    author
    		 statutory_interpretation Apr. 7, 2021
    U.S. v. Lucero
    author
    		 statutory_interpretation Mar. 5, 2021
    Axon Enterprise v. Federal Trade Commission
    dissenting
    		 Administrative Agencies Jan. 29, 2021
    U.S. v. Gear
    dissenting
    		 statutory_interpretation Jan. 20, 2021
    U.S. v. King
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jan. 15, 2021
    Langere v. Verizon Wireless Services
    author
    		 Arbitration Dec. 30, 2020
    Center for Investigative Reporting v. USDOJ
    dissenting
    		 statutory_interpretation Dec. 4, 2020
    State of California v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
    author
    		 Environmental Law Oct. 23, 2020
    Lockett v. County of Los Angeles
    author
    		 Civil Rights Oct. 5, 2020
    Amended Opinion: In re Nanette Sisk
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Sep. 25, 2020
    In re Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Sep. 11, 2020
    In re Augustine Pena III
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Sep. 8, 2020
    Syed v. Barr
    author
    		 Immigration Aug. 13, 2020
    Hanson v. Shubert
    concurring
    		 Civil Procedure Aug. 5, 2020
    United States v. Obagi
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jul. 20, 2020
    In re Nanette Marie Sisk
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Jun. 23, 2020
    In re Lenore L. Albert-Sheridan
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Jun. 11, 2020
    Case Category Published
    Garraway v. Ciufo
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Sep. 4, 2024
    Brown v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
    dissenting
    		 Tax Aug. 29, 2024
    Chong v. U.S.
    concurring
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 14, 2024
    Clements v. Madden
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 9, 2024
    Kumar v. Garland
    dissenting
    		 Immigration Aug. 5, 2024
    U.S. v. Hernandez
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jun. 28, 2024
    U.S. v. Leopoldo Rivera-Valdes
    concurring
    		 Immigration Jun. 17, 2024
    Sidibe v. Sutter Health
    dissenting
    		 Antitrust Jun. 4, 2024
    Walter Betschart v. State of Oregon
    dissenting
    		 Prisoners' Rights May 31, 2024
    Friends of the Inyo v. United States Forest Service
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law May 21, 2024
    BBK Tobacco & Foods LLP v. Central Coast Agriculture Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Intellectual Property Apr. 1, 2024
    U.S. v. Lemus
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Mar. 5, 2024
    Sherman v. Gittere
    author
    		 Prisoners' Rights Feb. 9, 2024
    Martinez v. High
    concurring
    		 Qualified Immunity Jan. 26, 2024
    Coalition on Homelessness v. City and County of San Francisco
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Jan. 11, 2024
    Amended Opinion: California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley
    author
    		 Environmental Law Jan. 2, 2024
    Miller v. City of Scottsdale
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Dec. 8, 2023
    Kohn v. State Bar of California
    dissenting
    		 Attorneys Dec. 6, 2023
    Amalgamated Bank v. Facebook, Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Securities Oct. 18, 2023
    Solar Energy Industries Assoc. v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law Sep. 5, 2023
    Oracle USA Inc. v. Rimini Street Inc.
    author
    		 Copyright Aug. 24, 2023
    Murguia v. Langdon
    dissenting
    		 Jul. 18, 2023
    Davis v. Cranfield Aerospace Solutions, Ltd.
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Jun. 23, 2023
    Enigma Software Group USA LLC v. Malwarebytes, Inc.
    dissenting
    		 Commercial Law Jun. 2, 2023
    Estate of Strickland v. Nevada County
    author
    		 Civil Rights May 31, 2023
    U.S. v. Williams
    author
    		 Attorneys May 18, 2023
    California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley
    author
    		 Environmental Law Apr. 17, 2023
    Duke v. Gastelo
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Apr. 5, 2023
    City of Los Angeles v. Federal Aviation Administration
    dissenting
    		 Environmental Law Mar. 29, 2023
    Seaview Trading LLC v. Commisssioner of Internal Revenue
    dissenting
    		 Tax Mar. 10, 2023
    Rodriguez Diaz v. Merrick Garland, et al
    concurring
    		 Constitutional Law Nov. 21, 2022
    In re: Sandra J. Tillman
    dissenting
    		 Bankruptcy Nov. 18, 2022
    Verdun v. City of San Diego
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Oct. 26, 2022
    Cody v. Kijakazi
    author
    		 Administrative Agencies Sep. 8, 2022
    Klamath Irrigation District v. Shasta View Irrigation District
    concurring
    		 Civil Procedure Sep. 8, 2022
    Vanegas v. City of Pasadena
    concurring
    		 Civil Rights Aug. 31, 2022
    Chicken Ranch Rancheria v. State of California
    dissenting
    		 Gaming Jul. 28, 2022
    U.S. v. Oliver
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jul. 22, 2022
    California River Watch v. City of Vacaville
    author
    		 Environmental Law Jul. 1, 2022
    U.S. v. David
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jun. 15, 2022
    Martinez v. Clark
    author
    		 Immigration Jun. 15, 2022
    Inter-Cooperative Exchange v. U.S. Dept. of Commerce
    author
    		 Government Jun. 7, 2022
    U.S. v. Randall
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure May 23, 2022
    Seaview Trading v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
    author
    		 Tax May 12, 2022
    U.S. v. Kirilyuk
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Apr. 4, 2022
    Amended Opinion: Martinez-Gonzalez v. Elkhorn Packing RULING BY
    author
    		 Arbitration Feb. 15, 2022
    U.S. v. Orrock
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jan. 27, 2022
    Johnson v. Baker
    author
    		 Civil Rights Jan. 27, 2022
    City of Oakland v. Oakland Raiders
    concurring
    		 Antitrust Dec. 3, 2021
    Duncan v. Bonta
    dissenting
    		 Constitutional Law Dec. 2, 2021
    D.D. v. Los Angeles Unified School District
    dissenting
    		 Disability Discrimination Nov. 22, 2021
    Center for Community Action v. Federal Aviation Administration
    concurring
    		 Environmental Law Nov. 19, 2021
    Martinez-Gonzalez v. Elkhorn Packing
    author
    		 Arbitration Nov. 4, 2021
    California River Watch v. City of Vacaville
    author
    		 Environmental Law Sep. 30, 2021
    Sanders v. City of Pittsburg
    author
    		 Civil Rights Sep. 24, 2021
    Center for Investigative Reporting v. U.S. Dept. of Justice
    dissenting
    		 Government Sep. 24, 2021
    Landis v. Wash. State MLB Stadium Pub. Facilities Dist.
    concurring
    		 Disability Discrimination Sep. 2, 2021
    U.S. v. Ferguson
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Aug. 18, 2021
    Bahr v. Regan
    concurring
    		 Environmental Law Jul. 29, 2021
    United States v. Charley
    concurring
    		 Evidence Jun. 14, 2021
    Magadia v. Wal-Mart Associates
    author
    		 Labor Law Jun. 1, 2021
    Olean Wholesale Grocery Cooperative, Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Apr. 7, 2021
    Diaz-Flores v. Garland
    author
    		 statutory_interpretation Apr. 7, 2021
    U.S. v. Lucero
    author
    		 statutory_interpretation Mar. 5, 2021
    Axon Enterprise v. Federal Trade Commission
    dissenting
    		 Administrative Agencies Jan. 29, 2021
    U.S. v. Gear
    dissenting
    		 statutory_interpretation Jan. 20, 2021
    U.S. v. King
    author
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jan. 15, 2021
    Langere v. Verizon Wireless Services
    author
    		 Arbitration Dec. 30, 2020
    Center for Investigative Reporting v. USDOJ
    dissenting
    		 statutory_interpretation Dec. 4, 2020
    State of California v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
    author
    		 Environmental Law Oct. 23, 2020
    Lockett v. County of Los Angeles
    author
    		 Civil Rights Oct. 5, 2020
    Amended Opinion: In re Nanette Sisk
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Sep. 25, 2020
    In re Volkswagen Clean Diesel Litigation
    author
    		 Civil Procedure Sep. 11, 2020
    In re Augustine Pena III
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Sep. 8, 2020
    Syed v. Barr
    author
    		 Immigration Aug. 13, 2020
    Hanson v. Shubert
    concurring
    		 Civil Procedure Aug. 5, 2020
    United States v. Obagi
    dissenting
    		 Criminal Law and Procedure Jul. 20, 2020
    In re Nanette Marie Sisk
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Jun. 23, 2020
    In re Lenore L. Albert-Sheridan
    author
    		 Bankruptcy Jun. 11, 2020
    By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy. You can learn more about how we use cookies by reviewing our Privacy Policy here.