Confidential
Settlement – $11,500,000Judge
Court
USDC Southern District of California
Attorneys
Plaintiff
Defendant
Experts
Plaintiff
David J. Yerke
(technical)
Robert M. Lea
(technical)
Defendant
Margaret E. Singleton
(technical)
John G. Ellis
(technical)
Brian P. Brinig
(technical)
Facts
The plaintiff condemned the historic Hotel San Diego for expansion of the federal courthouse
facilities. The plaintiff offered the defendant owners, SDH Properties, LLC, $7.7 million for the
property based on an appraisal. The appraiser subsequently revised his appraisal to reflect a fair
market value of $6.8 million. Appraisers retained by the property owners valued the property at $13.4 million and $14,160,000.
USA hired a second appraited who valued the property at $10.8 million.
'
Settlement Discussions
From the $11,500,000 settlement amount, the co-defendant lessees sought the following apportionment amounts: Burger King, business goodwill of $370,000, fixtures and leasehold improvements of $685, 183; Sushi Deli, leasehold bonus value of $8,190; Mrith Sririam (Po Color) leasehold bonus value of $18, 295; Pacific Coast Chinese & Thai Food, (unspecified amounts of leasehold bonus value and fixtures and equipment). Prior to trial, SDH offered $325,000 to settle the leasehold bonus value claim by Sushi Deli Express, which offer was rejected.
Result
The plaintiff agreed to pay $11.5 million for the condemned property.
Other Information
From the $11,500,000 settlement amount, the co-defendant lessees sought the following apportionment amounts: Burger King, business goodwill of $370,000, fixtures and leasehold improvements of $685,183; Sushi Deli, leasehold bonus value of $469,269, fixtures and leasehold improvements of $52,390; Mrith Sririam (Pro Color) leasehold bonus value of $18,295; Mr. Juice, lesehold bonus value of $8,190; Pacific Coast Chinese & Thai Food, (unspecified amounts of leasehold bonus value and fixtures and equipment). Before trial, the owners offered $325,000 to settle the leasehold bonus value claim by Sushi Deli Express, which offer was rejected. After trial on the lessees' apportionment claims, Judge Singleton awarded nothing to the lessees.
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
jeremy@reprintpros.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 949-702-5390