Alice Underwood in and through her Successor-In-Interest, Christine Swalve, and Christine Swalve, an individual v. Spring Valley Post Acute LLC, Meridian Management Services LLC, Victor Valley Global Medical Center, Victor Valley Hospital Acquisition Inc., Becky Underwood, Brenda Underwood and Stanley Underwood
Published: Mar. 15, 2019 | Result Date: Dec. 7, 2018 |Case number: 30-2016-00837584-CU-PO-CJC Verdict – $1,399,309
Judge
Court
Orange County Superior Court
Attorneys
Plaintiff
Michael F. Moran
(Moran Law)
Alexander H. Feldman
(Gharibian Law APC)
Damon A. Schwartz
(Moran Law)
Defendant
Curtis C. Holmes II
(West & Rosa LLP)
for Victor Valley Global Medical Center, Victor Valley Hospital Acquisition Inc.
Facts
Christine Swalve filed a wrongful death suit against Victor Valley Global Medical Center and Victor Valley Hospital Acquisition Inc. in relation to the death of her mother, Alice Underwood.
Contentions
PLAINTIFF'S CONTENTIONS: Swalve contended that her mother went to the defendants' hospital to treat a urinary tract infection and dehydration after hip surgery. While at defendant hospital, decedent's surgical incision became infected and she needed a procedure to remove the infection at a subsequent facility/hospital. Twenty-six days after the procedure, plaintiff's mother died. Swalve claimed defendants were negligent and did not assess decedent's incision and caused the infection and ultimately her wrongful death. Swalve also sued for elder abuse/neglect.
DEFENDANTS' CONTENTIONS: Defendants claimed that they did assess decedent's incision but they were not required to document the assessments under documentation by exception. They further claimed that they did not cause or contribute to decedent's death.
Settlement Discussions
Swalve demanded $249,999 under CCP Section 998. Defendants offered $95,000 under CCP Section 998.
Result
The jury rendered a verdict for Swalve and found the defendants were negligent and committed elder abuse/neglect in causing harm/death to the decedent. The jury found that the damages amounted to $1,399,308.73.
Other Information
Plaintiff will be filing post-trial motions for prejudgment interest (998) and attorney fees and costs pursuant to the jury's finding of elder abuse (enhanced remedies).
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
jeremy@reprintpros.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 949-702-5390