Facts

Los Padres Forestwatch was an organization geared towards restoring public lands, particularly in the Los Padres National Forest. After the approval of the Cuddy Valley Project, a vegetation treatment program for surrounding areas including the Los Padres Forrest, the LPFW and other similar organizations sought further environmental analysis from the Los Padres Forest Supervisor to ensure the project's compliance with applicable regulations.

PLAINTIFFS' CONTENTIONS: Plaintiffs contended defendants' approval of the Cuddy Valley Project was not categorically excluded from further environmental review because it intended to thin trees of all sizes in violation of applicable environmental law. Plaintiffs also contended that the manner in which defendants intended to thin the surrounding forest area was not protected by a categorical exception under the National Environmental Policy Act. Plaintiffs also contended that defendants failed to consider the aesthetic effect and deviation from desired area plans the Cuddy Valley Project presented in violation of the National Forest Management Act.

DEFENDANTS' CONTENTIONS: Defendant denied the contentions and contended that the Cuddy Valley Project was categorically exempt under the National Environmental Policy Act. Defendants further contended that all relevant and necessary factors were considered in the initial environmental report in compliance with the National Forest Management Act and were therefore entitled to summary judgment against plaintiffs.

Result

The court granted defendants' motion for summary judgment.

Other Information

Plaintiffs have appealed the ruling to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.