Facts

On May 13, 2017, Timothy Baggs, a U.S. Marine Corps recruiter, was driving with his wife, Mitsuru, seated in the passenger side, traveling on Crenshaw Boulevard in Torrance. As he was driving, their vehicle was rear-ended by a car being driven by Joseph Paparella, who was employed by Avanti Electric Co. After the collision, Timothy drove himself and Mitsuru to Providence Little Company of Mary Hospital in Torrance. The Baggs sued Paparella and Avanti Electric.

PLAINTIFFS' CONTENTIONS: Plaintiffs alleged that defendant was negligent in the operation of his vehicle, and as his employer, Avanti Electric was vicariously liable for Paparella's actions.

DEFENDANTS' CONTENTIONS: Defendants admitted liability for the collision but disputed the nature and extent of plaintiffs' treatments, arguing they were excessive and unnecessary, resulting in medical bills that were too high. No radiculopathy was shown for either plaintiff and thus did not need injections. Instead, plaintiffs' alleged injuries should have been resolved after undergoing chiropractic care.

Result

The jury determined a total award of $182,000. Timothy's damages totaled $136,000 which included $71,000 past medical cost and $65,000 past pain and suffering. As to Mitsuru, her damages totaled $46,000 which included $31,000 for past medical costs and $15,000 for past pain and suffering,

Deliberation

One hour

Poll

11-1

Length

Five days