Facts

In 1984 contamination was detected in Chico. In 1986, plaintiff California Department of Toxic Substances Control investigated the problem and initiated cleanup efforts.

PLAINTIFF'S CONTENTIONS:
The plaintiff contended that the defendants released hazardous substances from their respective locations and contaminated the drinking water in Chico.

DEFENDANTS' CONTENTIONS:
Defendant Peden contended Chico Unified School District drilled a well that spread the contamination. Defendants Noret and Weiss contended the Shillings, by operating Sunshine Cleaners, contributed to the contamination. Defendant Sunset View Cemetery Association contended Metcalf & Eddy, the firm hired to test the sewer line, also contributed to the contamination during their examination.

Damages

The plaintiff sought reimbursement for the cost of cleanup.

Result

The plaintiff recovered $11,920,00 ($5,100,00 from Sunset View Cemetery Association; $3,200,00 from Sunset View Cemetery Association and Peden, $50,000 from Peden; $100,000 from Chico Unified School District, $2,200,000 from the city of Chico, $220,000 from Noret and Weiss, and $45,000 from the Shillings.) The California Water Service Company will construct and operate facilities, which will be part of the groundwater cleanup, the net present value of which is $3,100,000.

Other Information

FILING DATE: Feb. 28, 2002.