Edith Matthai

Los Angeles

Legal Malpractice Defense & Judicial Discipline Defense

Confidentiality is of utmost importance in Edith R. Matthai's line of work as a representative for lawyers and judges. While some aspects of her cases may receive media attention, it is not initiated by her or the clients she represents.

"When I am representing a judge before the Commission on Judicial Performance, my primary goal is to ensure that the details of the case remain undisclosed. This can only be achieved if the commission decides not to impose any discipline or if the disciplinary action is kept private," Matthai said. "Consequently, my mission revolves around preventing any information from being leaked to the press or being disclosed in any other manner. It is crucial to maintain the privacy and integrity of the CJP disciplinary system."

"Nor do the attorneys I represent want their cases to be publicized," she added.

Reflecting on recent cases, one that stands out is Judge Michael F. Murray's case in Orange County. It proceeded to formal proceedings, which were public. However, the process before the public hearing lasted for nearly four years, with a series of then private back-and-forth communications through investigation letters and responses, ultimately leading to the formal proceedings, which are public.

Formal Proceedings take place before three special masters appointed by the California Supreme Court. The commission typically resorts to formal proceedings when they have the intention to remove a judge from their position.

"When they believe they have a strong chance of succeeding," she explained.

However, all charges against Murray were ultimately dismissed, which, to her knowledge, is the only matter in which all charges have been dismissed after formal proceedings.

"It is a source of pride for me to have achieved such a positive outcome," she noted.

Matthai co-founded Robie & Matthai APC in 1975 with her late husband, James R. Robie. Their daughter, Leigh P. Robie, is now a member of the boutique firm that focuses principally on professional responsibility matters. However, some changes are underway for the firm.

"I have come to a pivotal decision in my career. I have decided to leave my current practice and embark on a new journey as a full-time neutral at JAMS," she said. "This transition will allow me to apply my knowledge and expertise in alternative dispute resolution, providing a fair and unbiased approach to resolving conflicts."

Matthai will shutter the practice after 48 years as a practicing lawyer. Her daughter and other lawyers from the firm will become the Los Angeles office of Long & Levit LLP, which also represents judges and lawyers.

-Douglas Saunders