Facts

Plaintiff Gerry Hovland was driving through an intersection. His vehicle struck the side of Dede House's car. Thereafter, a car driven by Blanca Camberos struck the rear of plaintiff's car. Plaintiff filed suit against House; the owner of the vehicle the was driving, John McGinnity; and Camberos.

PLAINTIFF'S CONTENTIONS:
Plaintiff claimed that House had run a red light. Plaintiff alleged that the impact from Camberos’ car was more severe, and caused his injuries. He also claimed he was unable to work as a result of his injuries.

DEFENDANT'S CONTENTIONS:
None

Settlement Discussions

Plaintiff demanded $300,000. Camberos offered $8,500, and McGinnity and House offered $20,000.

Specials in Evidence

Plaintiff submitted $30,000 in past medical bills. Plaintiff requested $150,000 in lost income.

Damages

Plaintiff sought $30,000 in general damages.

Injuries

Plaintiff sustained injuries to his neck, back, left shoulder, and left side. He also claimed a torn rotator cuff, which required surgery. He also suffered from headaches, nausea, vertigo, dizziness, anxiety, and emotional distress.

Result

The jury determined that Camberos was not negligent, nor a significant cause of injury to plaintiff. Camberos was awarded costs of $18,685.60. The jury awarded plaintiff $5,000 in past medical costs, $10,000 in lost income, and $30,000 in general damages, totaling $50,000 from House and McGinnity.

Other Information

Plaintiff filed a motion to tax costs.

Deliberation

90 minutes

Poll

11-1

Length

six days