Facts

On April 18, 2011, there was an electrical fire at Mildred Tolbert's home, resulting in smoke and water damage. In order to fight the fire originating from the ground, the Compton Fire Dept. also broke through the house's floorboards. After the fire was deemed an "arching event", Tolbert filed a claim with Allstate Insurance Co., her fire and casualty insurance carrier. Allstate paid the claim.

PLAINTIFF'S CONTENTIONS:
Allstate filed suit against Southern California Edison Co., Tolbert's electricity provider, alleging liability for a defect causing excess voltage of electricity. Allstate contended that the excess voltage entered the home causing the arcing event, due to Southern California's negligence.

DEFENDANT'S CONTENTIONS:
Southern California denied delivering any excess voltage, contending the home's internal electrical system was faulty, causing the fire.

Damages

Allstate sought $88,000 in property damages and living expenses for Tolbert while she was displaced from her home.

Result

The court rendered a verdict for the defense.