Facts

Robert Herskowitz filed a class action against Apple Inc. Phoebe Juel aso filed a class action against Apple. Their class actions related to Apple's alleged practice of routinely and unlawfully charging it "e-Store" customers more than once for the same products in violation of consumer laws.

PLAINTIFFS' CONTENTIONS:
Plaintiffs alleged that Apple charged its e-Store customers repeatedly for the same products. Plaintiffs alleged that Apple's double billing violated various consumer laws. Plaintiffs filed a motion to certify three classes, the "Fifteen-Minute" class, the "Unusable Product" class, and the "Active e-Stores Account" class.

DEFENDANT'S CONTENTIONS:
Apple opposed plaintiffs' motion for class certification, arguing that the court should not grant it because it was not amenable to class-wide adjudication.

Result

U.S. District Court Judge Lucy H. Koh denied plaintiff's motion for class certification in its entirety.